Marco Williams
If your dog destroys every toy within hours, you already know the frustration — another replacement from the pet store, another $20 gone in minutes. Dog subscription boxes promise to solve this with monthly deliveries of purpose-built toys, but for power chewers especially, choosing the wrong box means wasted money and a bored dog by lunchtime.
Bullymake and BarkBox Super Chewer look similar on paper — same price, same monthly delivery — but they’re built for completely different dogs. Whether you’re searching bullymake vs barkbox or barkbox vs bullymake, this guide gives you a direct answer based on your dog’s actual chewing level.
Bullymake vs BarkBox Super Chewer — Quick Verdict
★★★★☆ Bullymake: 4.4/5 (~2,000 Trustpilot reviews) ★★★★☆ BarkBox Super Chewer: 4.1/5 (8,500+ Trustpilot reviews)
Choose Bullymake if:
- Your dog destroys toys within hours, not days
- You have a large or XL breed (60 lbs+): Pitbull, Rottweiler, Cane Corso, Mastiff, or German Shepherd
- You want a toys-only box with no treats at all
- You want to choose specific toy materials — nylon-only for the toughest chewers
Choose BarkBox Super Chewer if:
- Your dog is a small to medium breed (under 50 lbs) or a moderate chewer
- Creative monthly themes and toy variety matter as much as raw durability
- Your dog has multiple food allergies requiring broader customization
- You want a no-photo, no-time-limit replacement guarantee
If your dog has already destroyed BarkBox Super Chewer toys, Bullymake is the logical next step.
What Is the Difference Between Bullymake and BarkBox?
Bullymake was founded in 2014 by a former BarkBox customer frustrated with toy durability. Every design decision prioritizes structural survival — toys are engineered to last as long as possible, not to look fun or follow a theme. It serves one dog type: the one that destroys everything.
BarkBox Super Chewer is BARK’s premium durability line, built as an upgrade to the standard BarkBox. With over 8 million subscribers served, BarkBox is the largest dog subscription brand in the US — Super Chewer is its premium durability tier. The philosophy differs fundamentally from Bullymake: for the barkbox super chewer vs bullymake decision, the key distinction is that Super Chewer toys are purposely designed to eventually break apart safely, while Bullymake toys are built to last as long as possible.
Both brands sit at the same entry-level price on annual plans. The gap is not in cost — it is in what each box prioritizes, which dog size it serves best, and how strict or generous the guarantee is when toys fall short.
Bullymake vs BarkBox: Which One Is Better for Your Dog?
Bullymake is built for aggressive chewers and large power-breed dogs, while BarkBox Super Chewer focuses more on variety, enrichment, and flexible replacement support.
| Factor | Bullymake | BarkBox Super Chewer | Best Choice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best For | Aggressive chewers | Variety & enrichment | Depends on dog |
| Starting Price | $29/month | $30/month | Bullymake |
| Shipping | $4 on multi-month plans | Free in most U.S. states | BarkBox |
| Toy Durability | Extreme durability focus | Durable but safer break-apart design | Bullymake |
| Treat Variety | Optional treats | More treats & chews included | BarkBox |
| Replacement Policy | 45 days + photo required | No photo, easier replacements | BarkBox |
| Allergy Options | 3 filters | 6 filters | BarkBox |
| Best Dog Size | Large/XL breeds | Small to large breeds | BarkBox |
| USA Manufacturing Transparency | Clearer sourcing | Mixed sourcing | Bullymake |
| Overall Value for Power Chewers | Excellent | Good | Bullymake |
Pricing — Which Plan Gives the Best Value?
| Plan | Bullymake | BarkBox Super Chewer |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Plan | $45/box | $45/box |
| 3-Month Plan | $37/box | Not available |
| 6-Month Plan | $33/box | $35/box |
| Best Annual Price | $29/box | $30/box |
| Shipping | $4/month | Free shipping |
| Best For | Extreme chewers | Better overall convenience |
Bullymake’s 12-month plan is $1/month cheaper on paper, but BarkBox Super Chewer ships free to the contiguous US. Once you factor in Bullymake’s $4/month shipping fee on multi-month plans, BarkBox Super Chewer works out to around $36 less per year all in. That said, Bullymake’s $19 first box deal plus free poop bags makes the entry price genuinely low for first-timers.
Choose Bullymake if you want the toys-only configuration and you’re confident you’ll stay the full plan term. Choose BarkBox Super Chewer if total annual cost matters and free shipping is important to you.
⚠ Do not subscribe to a multi-month plan on either service unless you’re confident it’s the right fit for your dog. Bullymake charges an early cancellation fee if you exit before completing your plan. BarkBox Super Chewer requires you to receive and pay for every committed box before cancellation takes effect.
What’s Inside Each Box?
| Bullymake | BarkBox Super Chewer | |
|---|---|---|
| Standard box | 2–3 tough toys + 3 treat bags | 2 tough toys + 2 treat bags + 2 meaty chews |
| Toys-only option | 4 toys, no treats (no extra charge) | Contact CS to request — may vary |
| Extra toy add-on | Not available | +$9/month |
| Toy materials | Nylon, Rubber, Rope, Ballistic, Plush | Rubber, Nylon (no plush in Super Chewer) |
| Treat sourcing | Made in USA. Grain-free. | Made in USA or Canada. Corn/soy/wheat-free. |
| Allergy options | Beef, chicken, grain | Chicken, turkey, beef, wheat, soy, corn |
| Rawhide included? | Never | Not in Super Chewer boxes |
BarkBox Super Chewer includes more edible items per box — 4 total versus Bullymake’s 3. But Bullymake’s free toys-only switch is the cleaner solution for treat-sensitive dogs. You get 4 tough toys per box at no extra charge, selected at signup or updated any time through your account portal.
BarkBox Super Chewer’s meaty chews are made in the USA or Canada and built to occupy a dog longer than a standard treat bag. For dogs that are as motivated by food as they are by toys, that’s a real advantage.
Choose Bullymake if your dog has treat sensitivities or you want maximum toys per box. Choose BarkBox Super Chewer if your dog is treat-motivated and high-protein meaty chews matter to them.
Toy Durability — Does Bullymake vs BarkBox Super Chewer Actually Make a Difference?
| Feature | Bullymake | BarkBox Super Chewer |
|---|---|---|
| Durability Focus | Maximum toughness | Tough but safer break-apart design |
| Toughest Material | Solid nylon | Hard nylon |
| Other Materials | Rubber, rope, ballistic, plush | Rubber + mixed toy styles |
| Best For | Aggressive chewers | Moderate chewers |
| Ideal Dog Size | Large/power breeds | Small to large dogs |
| Customization | Choose toy material | Based on play style |
Both brands use nylon and rubber — the same peak durability materials. The gap is design philosophy: Bullymake builds to last; BarkBox Super Chewer builds for safe, eventual failure. For dogs that destroy toys in under a day, that difference is decisive.
Nylon is the toughest material either brand offers. Bullymake’s nylon toys are a single solid piece with no stuffing or fabric — bite marks and surface wear are expected and completely normal. They’re also tested to withstand 3,500+ PSI, which is roughly four times the bite force of even the strongest dog breeds. BarkBox Super Chewer’s nylon toys can include fabric elements in some designs, so individual toy durability varies more month to month.
For breeds that apply extreme jaw pressure — Pitbulls, Rottweilers, Cane Corsos, Mastiffs, and German Shepherds — Bullymake’s nylon-only configuration is the right call. These breeds typically work through medium-density rubber within hours.
Choose Bullymake if your dog destroys toys within hours or has already gone through BarkBox Super Chewer toys before. Choose BarkBox Super Chewer if your dog is a committed chewer but toys typically last at least a few days.
Still deciding? Compare what arrives in each first box before committing to a plan.
Guarantee — What Happens When Your Dog Destroys a Toy?
| Feature | Bullymake | BarkBox Super Chewer |
|---|---|---|
| Replacement Window | 45 days | No stated time limit |
| Proof Required | Photo required | No photo required |
| Replacement Policy | 1 replacement/month | More flexible support |
| Refunds Offered | Replacement only | Replacement only |
| Overall Experience | More structured | Easier, customer-friendly |
BarkBox Super Chewer’s guarantee is more generous by every measure — no deadline, no photo, no monthly cap. Bullymake’s is stricter: you have 45 days, you need a photo, and you can only replace one toy per month regardless of how many were destroyed. For the super chewer barkbox vs bullymake guarantee comparison, BarkBox wins clearly on paper.
In practice, if Bullymake toys are being destroyed and replaced regularly within the guarantee window, the right fix is requesting nylon-only boxes. Switching to nylon typically ends the replacement cycle entirely.
Neither brand offers a cash refund. Both send a different toy as the replacement. If a monetary refund is what you need, neither subscription is the right fit.
Choose BarkBox Super Chewer if guarantee flexibility and ease of replacement matter most. Choose Bullymake if you’re confident in nylon’s durability and want clearly written guarantee terms.
Cancellation — Read This Before You Subscribe
This is the section most buyers skip — and the source of the most documented complaints for both brands.
Bullymake:
- 1-month plan ($45/box): Cancel anytime, zero fee. The most flexible option.
- 3-month ($37), 6-month ($33), 12-month ($29): Locked in for the full commitment. Exit early and a one-time cancellation fee applies.
- How to cancel: Email customercare@bullymake.com or use the live chat on the website. No phone support.
- You can also disable auto-renewal at any time, which stops future charges after your current term ends without triggering a cancellation fee.
BarkBox Super Chewer:
- 1-month plan ($45/box): Cancel anytime.
- 6-month ($35) and 12-month ($30): You must receive and pay for every committed box before cancellation takes effect. There is no early exit.
- How to cancel: Via your account portal or customer service.
The complaints about Bullymake on Reddit, Trustpilot, and the BBB are real. They’re not isolated cases — they come almost entirely from multi-month subscribers who didn’t read the cancellation terms at signup. The toys themselves get strong reviews. The frustration is the early exit fee, which is technically disclosed in the terms but not prominently flagged at checkout.
The fix is simple: start on the monthly plan.
⚠ Start on the monthly plan for your first box on either service. Upgrade to a longer commitment only after confirming the box works for your dog — in both toy durability and treat compatibility.
Neither brand is difficult to cancel on a monthly plan. Every documented problem comes from multi-month commitments. Choose monthly first.
Small Dogs vs Large Dogs — Which Box Fits Better?
| Dog Size | Recommended | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Under 30 lbs | BarkBox Super Chewer | Better toy size range, more small-breed options |
| 30–60 lbs (moderate chewer) | BarkBox Super Chewer | Good balance of durability and variety |
| 30–60 lbs (aggressive chewer) | Bullymake | Nylon handles intense jaw pressure better |
| 60 lbs+ (power chewer) | Bullymake | Built specifically for large-breed power chewers |
| 60 lbs+ (moderate chewer) | Either works | Choose based on treat preference and theme interest |
Bullymake sizes boxes by dog weight but designs all toys for power chewers. Multiple owner reviews note that very small dogs struggle to engage with Bullymake toys — they can be too large or too dense for breeds under 20–25 lbs.
BarkBox Super Chewer explicitly sizes for small, medium, and large dogs, with toy dimensions scaled to match. For dogs under 30 lbs, that size-matching is a genuine practical advantage.
Decision: Large breed power chewer → Bullymake. Small to medium dog → BarkBox Super Chewer.
Who Should Skip Both Subscriptions?
- Dogs with rare or complex allergies beyond the listed options — use Bullymake’s free toys-only option, or contact BarkBox Super Chewer to confirm they can accommodate your dog’s needs
- Owners who can’t commit financially to $29–$45/month consistently — start on the monthly plan and evaluate before extending
- Gentle chewers or dogs that aren’t particularly toy-motivated — standard BarkBox (not Super Chewer) is a more appropriate and less expensive starting point
- Dogs on prescription food or medical diets — check with your vet before introducing any new treats
- Buyers expecting a cash refund if dissatisfied — neither brand offers monetary refunds, only toy replacements
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Bullymake better than BarkBox Super Chewer?
For extreme chewers and large breeds, yes — bullymake vs barkbox favors Bullymake when raw durability is the priority. Toys are built to last across five toy material types, with a free toys-only option no other major subscription offers. BarkBox Super Chewer is the stronger pick for small to medium dogs, owners who need more allergy flexibility, and buyers who value a no-time-limit replacement guarantee. Neither brand is universally better. Your dog’s jaw strength and size should make the call.
Is Bullymake worth the price?
For power chewer households, yes. A single high-durability toy from a pet store costs around $20–$25. Dogs that destroy two or three per month spend more going retail than subscribing. Bullymake holds a 4.4-star rating across nearly 2,000 Trustpilot reviews, with most owners pointing to nylon toys lasting far longer than anything they found in stores. The main risk is the early cancellation fee on multi-month plans. Start on the monthly plan at $45 and upgrade only after confirming the toys hold up for your dog.
Is BarkBox Super Chewer good for aggressive chewers?
It depends on the aggression level. For dogs that chew hard but don’t destroy toys within 24 hours, Super Chewer holds up well and delivers real monthly variety. For extreme chewers — Rottweilers, Pitbulls, Cane Corsos, Mastiffs — Super Chewer toys may not survive day one. BarkBox’s own documentation says toys are designed to eventually break apart safely, not to outlast the chewer indefinitely. If your dog falls into the extreme category, Bullymake’s nylon-only setup is the more appropriate choice.
Is Bullymake good for a Pitbull?
Yes — Bullymake is one of the best-suited subscriptions for Pitbulls specifically. Pitbulls apply enough jaw pressure to routinely work through medium-density rubber within hours. Bullymake’s nylon toys are a single solid piece with no stuffing or fabric components — bite marks are expected but structural failure is rare. Select nylon as your material preference post-signup. At $29–$45/month depending on your plan, it replaces what most Pitbull owners spend on destroyed store-bought toys anyway.
How do I cancel Bullymake?
On the 1-month plan, email customercare@bullymake.com or use the live chat on the website at any time — no fee applies. On a 3-, 6-, or 12-month plan, canceling before completing your commitment triggers a one-time early cancellation fee. There is no phone support. You can also disable auto-renewal at any time, which stops future charges after your current term ends without requiring an early exit. Start on the monthly plan to avoid any of these complications.
What is the cheapest way to try Bullymake?
Right now, the first box on any multi-month plan is $19 plus free poop bags — a genuine saving off the $45 month-to-month rate. The catch is that it commits you to 3, 6, or 12 months with an early cancellation fee if you leave early. If flexibility matters more than the first-box price, start monthly at $45 with no strings attached. Promo code BULLYMAKE5 takes $5 off your first order on any plan. Think carefully about whether the $26 saving on the first box is worth the commitment risk.
Are the complaints about Bullymake on Reddit accurate?
Yes — the cancellation fee complaints on Reddit, Trustpilot, and the BBB are real and documented. They come almost entirely from multi-month subscribers who tried to exit before completing their plan. The toys themselves get consistently strong reviews from power chewer owners — nylon durability is the brand’s genuine strength. The issue is the early cancellation fee, which is disclosed in the terms but not prominently shown at checkout. The mitigation is simple: start on the 1-month plan and only upgrade once you’re confident the box is right for your dog.
Final Verdict
For power chewers and large breeds, Bullymake is the stronger pick. Tougher materials, a free toys-only option, clearer USA sourcing, and a higher Trustpilot rating — offset by stricter guarantee terms and a shipping fee on multi-month plans.
For moderate chewers, small-to-medium dogs, and owners who value variety, creative themes, and a more generous guarantee, BarkBox Super Chewer is the better fit. Free shipping on all US plans makes it the cheaper annual option once everything is accounted for.
Both brands start at the same month-to-month price. Your dog’s jaw strength and size should make the final call — not the marketing.
Make your decision based on your dog’s actual chewing level.
(Best for power chewers and large breeds)
(Best for moderate chewers and smaller dogs — verify offer at checkout)
